21 Nov 2026, Sat

Gap Earned 30% More on Flat Sales. Ross Grew Everything and Still Got Punished.

When two retailers beat earnings on the same night and both trade lower, the market is not being irrational. It is making a distinction. The question worth asking is whether it is making the right one.

Ross Stores delivered what should have been a clean win. Total sales rose 12% to $6.3 billion, comparable store sales increased 8% on top of a 7% gain last year, and earnings per share came in at $1.91. Operating margin rose 70 basis points to 12.3% from 11.6%. Traffic drove every bit of it. Management said comparable-store sales were “primarily driven by customer traffic.” The stock still fell roughly 5% after hours to around $208.75, having already closed down before the report.

The culprit was Q4 guidance. Ross maintained its Q4 comparable store sales outlook of up 4% to 5% and EPS of $2.16 to $2.25 versus $2.00 last year. The company said those Q4 comps are on top of a 9% gain last year. That is what spooked the market, not the quarter itself.

Gap’s situation reads differently on the surface. Earnings per share were $0.86, up over 30% versus last year. SG&A came in at 32.6% of net sales. Margin management, in other words, did the work that revenue did not. Net sales of $4.0 billion were up 2% year over year, with comparable sales flat.

The brand scorecard inside Gap’s portfolio is where the real tension lives. The Gap brand posted net sales up 11% with comparable sales up 9%, its 12th consecutive quarter of positive comparable sales. Old Navy, which represents the majority of the company’s revenue, was flat. Banana Republic comparable sales declined 3%, while Athleta comparable sales fell 15%. Gap named Ashley Kechter as Athleta’s next President and CEO to lead a reset, but a 15% comparable sales decline signals the turnaround has not yet taken hold.

Then Gap lowered its forward outlook. Gap lowered its full-year outlook, now expecting net sales to be roughly flat compared with its previous forecast for growth of 1% to 1.5%. Management cited unseasonably warm weather softening demand in October and early November.

So here is the choice. Ross is a business genuinely gaining customers, raising its full-year EPS guidance, buying back stock aggressively, and cycling difficult comparisons with momentum intact. Management raised fiscal 2026 earnings per share guidance to between $8.75 and $8.84, while continuing capital returns via $319 million in share repurchases and a quarterly dividend of $0.445 per share. The Q4 step-down in comp guidance reflects math, not deterioration. Gap, meanwhile, is earning more money by cutting costs rather than by growing its customer base. That is a meaningful difference.

Ross at $208.75 is not cheap, but it is being penalized for a guidance deceleration that is largely mechanical. Gap at $18.79 is getting credit for profitability that rests on a crumbling Athleta and a flat Old Navy. The market sold both. The better-quality business was Ross, and the after-hours dip offered the cleaner entry.